DEAR FRANKIE — CANNES 2004

by

Welcome!

ColeSmithey.com

Groupthink doesn't live here, critical thought does.

This ad-free website is dedicated to Agnès Varda and to Luis Buñuel. Punk heart still beating.


Get cool rewards when you click on the button to pledge your support through .

Thanks a lot acorns!

Your kind generosity keeps the reviews coming!

ColeSmithey.com

Miramax Tearjerker Sees the Light of Day


Shona Auerbach’s Touching Glasgow Drama Soars


By Cole Smithey

ColeSmithey.comDebut director Shona Auerbach’s touching story of a single mother and her hearing- impaired son was a charmer at the Cannes Film Festival but got caught in a release date abyss prolonged by the split between Miramax and Disney.

The supremely understated Emily Mortimer ("Notting Hill") plays a single mother who must constantly change her address in order to avoid an abusive ex-husband who stalks her.

But Lizzie’s most immediate concern rests with providing hope for her deaf son Frankie (Jake McElhone) by fueling a white lie about his dad being a crewman on a cargo ship sailing around the world.

ColeSmithey.com

Lizzie ghostwrites letters from Frankie’s ideal dad until the ship that he supposedly sails on docks in Glasgow harbor. Lizzie hires a stranger (Gerard Butler) to meet Frankie and pose as his father.

Although the story is objectively fraught with sentimental pitfalls, Auerbach's distinctively talented cast embody the characters with a guileless purity that puts nuance where you’d commonly see glad-handed self reference.

ColeSmithey.com

Shona Auerbach is a former still photographer. She brings a keen eye for the story’s working class Glasgow locations that have a timeless and rugged quality. When Frankie studies a global map, where he traces the routes that his dad’s ship follows, we appreciate the child's need to imbue the outside world with an intimate knowledge that however real or imagined serves a practical purpose of maintaining an important bond with his mother.

These aren’t people who verbally profess their love, but rather consistently commit to actions that speak for themselves. There is something tragically tender about a mother ghost-writing letters to her son in order to protect him from a truth she knows she must eventually reconcile.

ColeSmithey.com

Frankie befriends a contentious classmate named Ricky and invites him into his humble apartment. Ricky soon seizes on information he gleans there to bait Frankie. Ricky notices a newspaper article reporting the ship Frankie’s father is sailing on has arrived in Glasgow’s port. Ricky bets with Frankie that Frankie’s father won’t attend their Saturday soccer game.

ColeSmithey.com

The emotional shades of the story take on special depth as Lizzie relies on her friend Marie (Sharon Small), who works as a cashier at the local fish market, to help her find a man to serve as a proxy dad to Frankie for a day. Lizzie is careful to make clear to Butler's nameless character that this is strictly a business deal.

Frankie begins to play his own hand at protecting his mother. We’re never quite sure about how much Frankie suspects that the man isn’t really his father, but we see his buoyant efforts to fully enjoy the opportunity afforded him. Jake McElhone gives a brilliant performance as a child actor that speaks volumes. The portrayal invariably gives voice to aspects of his mother’s latent desires and to those of the man she hires to give physical form to her idea of essential recognition.

ColeSmithey.com

Frankie’s hearing loss is an aftereffect of abuse he suffered as a baby from his biological father. For Lizzie the disability is a daily reminder of the danger that men pose. But it’s also a character trait of her son that causes her to paint an ideal portrait of what Frankie’s father should be.

ColeSmithey.com

There’s an instinctual therapy at work in Lizzie’s actions toward her son, and he in turn responds instinctively to fulfill his part of her projected desires. "Dear Frankie" is a movie that carefully exposes the universal onion layers of a unique familial bond without ever leaving fingerprints on the layers. There’s a lot to enjoy in this sophisticated romantic drama.

Rated PG-13. 102 mins.

4 Stars

FEATURED VIDEO
Smart New Media Custom Videos
Cole Smithey’s Movie Week
COLE SMITHEY’S CLASSIC CINEMA
La Grande Bouffe
Rotten Tomatoes

0 STAR REVIEWS
1 STAR REVIEWS
2 STAR REVIEWS
3 STAR REVIEWS
4 STAR REVIEWS
5 STAR REVIEWS
5th & Park Walking Tour
92NY
AAN
AER Music
AFI Silver Theatre & Cultural Center
AFRICAN AMERICAN CINEMA REVIEWS
AGITPROP REVIEWS
Alhambra Guitarras
Andy Singer
Angelika Film Center
Anthology Film Archives
Anti-War
Archer Aviation
ARCHITECTURAL STYLES OF CARNEGIE HILL WALKING TOUR
Argo Pictures
Barbuto
BDSM REVIEWS
Bellisimo Hats
Bemelmans Bar At The Carlyle
Big Bad Voodoo Daddy
Big Sur Kate
BIOPIC REVIEWS
BIRDLAND
Birdsall House Craft Beer Gastropub
BLACK AND WHITE REVIEWS
Bob Gruen
BOSSA NOVA
BRITISH CINEMA REVIEWS
Buzzcocks
Calton Cases
CANNES FESTIVAL REVIEWS
Carnegie Hill Concerts
Carnegie Hill Walking Tour
Catraio Craft Beer Shop
CHILDRENS CINEMA REVIEWS
CHINESE CINEMA REVIEWS
Church of Heavenly Rest
Cibo Ristorante Italiano
Cinémathèque Française ‘Henri’ Streaming
CLASSIC CINEMA REVIEWS
Cole’s Patreon Page
Cooper Hewitt Smithsonian Design Museum
COURTROOM DRAMA REVIEWS
COZY COLE
CozyColeSoloBossaNovaGuitar
CRITERION CHANNEL
Criterion Collection
CRITERION REVIEWS
Criterion24/7
Criterioncast
CULT FILM REVIEWS
DANISH CINEMA REVIEWS
EROTIC CINEMA REVIEWS
DOCUMENTARY REVIEWS
DYSTOPIAN CINEMA REVIEWS
FRENCH CINEMA REVIEWS
GAMBLING MOVIE REVIEWS
HORROR FILM REVIEWS
HUNGARIAN CINEMA REVIEWS
INDEPENDENT CINEMA REVIEWS
JAPANESE CINEMA REVIEWS
KOREAN CINEMA REVIEWS
LADY BIRD REVISITED
LGBTQ REVIEWS
LITERARY ADAPTATION REVIEWS
MARTIAL ARTS REVIEWS
MEXICAN CINEMA REVIEWS
Museum Mile Walking Tour
NEO-NOIR REVIEWS
NEW GERMAN CINEMA REVIEWS
FILM NOIR REVIEWS
OSCARS MOVIE REVIEWS
POLITICAL SATIRE REVIEWS
PORN REVIEWS
PSYCHOLOGICAL THRILLER REVIEWS
PUNK MOVIE REVIEWS
ROMANTIC COMEDY REVIEWS
SCREWBALL COMEDY REVIEWS
SEX MOVIE REVIEWS
SEXPLOITATION MOVIE REVIEWS
SHAKESPEARE CINEMA REVIEWS
SHOCKTOBER! REVIEWS
SILENT MOVIE REVIEWS
SOCIAL SATIRE REVIEWS
SPORTS COMEDY REVIEWS
SPORTS DRAMA REVIEWS
SURFING MOVIE REVIEWS
TRANSGRESSIVE CINEMA REVIEWS
WOMEN FILMMAKER REVIEWS
WOMENS CINEMA REVIEWS
VIDEO ESSAYS

keyboard_arrow_up